What to Order When You Can't Decide
Twenty-eight-plus flavors, a full sundae menu, shakes, malts, and floats. We've watched a lot of people freeze up at the counter, and we've come to think of it as a compliment.
Here's a map. The full list lives on our menu page.
If you want to taste the ice cream itself
Get a scoop. Cup or a fresh-pressed waffle cone.
Small is $5.49 for one scoop, medium $6.49 for two, large $7.49 for three. A pint to go is $9.99.
Fair warning: our scoops are dense — high butterfat, very little air — so a small here goes further than a small elsewhere. Start smaller than you think.
And ask for a taste first. That's what the little spoons are for, and nobody's in a hurry. Today's flavors are here.
If you want something to drink
Shakes, floats, and malts — $6.99.
Shakes get made with the flavor of your choice. The lineup includes Banana Cream Pie, Cookie Butter, Fruity Pebble, Nutella, Oreo, Peanut Butter Brownie, and S'mores.
Malts are any ice cream with malt ball blended in — an underordered classic that deserves better.
Floats are where it gets fun. Apple Pie Float with apple cider, ginger ale, and caramel. Creamsicle with orange soda. Purple Cow with grape soda. Salted Caramel with root beer. Shirley Temple with Sprite and grenadine. Or build your own with whatever soda you want.
If you came here to commit
Specialty sundaes and banana splits — $8.99.
The Elvis: vanilla, hot fudge, bananas, peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups. Exactly as advertised.
Brownie Boat: ice cream on a homemade brownie, whipped cream, chocolate syrup, cherry.
Dirt Sundae: chocolate ice cream, gummy worms, Oreos. Ordered almost exclusively by children and by adults being honest with themselves.
Also on the list: the classic Banana Split, Hot Fudge, Hot Chocolate, German Chocolate, Hawaiian, Rocky Road, S'mores, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Banana, Banana Cream, and Breakfast for Dessert — which is ice cream with cereal, and which we stand behind completely.
If you can't have dairy
You're covered — here's what we keep dairy-free.
If you still can't decide
Ask whoever's behind the counter what they'd get. They'll tell you, they'll be right, and they'll let you taste it first.
Flavors rotate weekly, so today's list is on the Ice Cream Flavors page — and we post the new ones on Instagram.